Critics described the storylines as "scattershot" and "nonsensical," often feeling like a "movie-a-week" filler for the Netflix catalog.
Reviewers often noted that the dialogue felt "Disney-like" or hyper-stylized, failing to capture how real high schoolers speak. Tall Girl 2
Many praised the performances of Griffin Gluck (Dunkleman), Sabrina Carpenter (Harper), and the comedic timing of Steve Zahn and Angela Kinsey as Jodi's parents. Sabrina Carpenter (Harper)
A low score of 35 out of 100 , indicating "generally unfavorable" reviews. IMDb: User ratings hover around 4.7/10 . Key Review Themes Tall Girl 2