Trey and his friend Jimmy (Castañeda) arrive at the same motel to hide evidence. Charlie's ability to detect lies becomes a survival tool as she realizes her "companions" are responsible for her injuries and a previous murder.

Critics praised the guest performances, particularly Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Stephanie Hsu, and the episode's "Fargo-like" atmosphere.

Charlie survives the hit and crawls to a nearby motel, where she encounters Morty (Stephanie Hsu), a kleptomaniac snowboarder she had met earlier.

Trey (Gordon-Levitt), a wealthy criminal under house arrest, takes advantage of a power outage that disables his ankle monitor to go for a joyride in his Lamborghini. During the blizzard, he accidentally runs over Charlie and, believing she is dead, dumps her body.