Many users on Steam and Big Fish Games warn that the puzzles are "astoundingly obtuse" and often lack logical consistency.
Some reviewers note that the English translation is awkward, making the story and certain puzzle clues difficult to follow. The Verdict Evil Pumpkin: The Lost Halloween
Reviewers on Adventure Gamers and Steam highlight the "scary beautiful" hand-drawn graphics and detailed environments. Many users on Steam and Big Fish Games
The game is filled with puns, ludicrous comments, and imaginative, twisted characters that differentiate it from more serious horror titles. Evil Pumpkin: The Lost Halloween